Is Brown Bread Good for Weight Loss?
Each article on the fitterfly website is a labor of love, reviewed by a team of certified medical experts specializing in various fields like Diabetology, Nutrition, Physiotherapy, Psychology.
They carefully examine all references and facts to provide up-to-date and reliable information, aiming to break myths and empower you in your health journey.
Meet Our Reviewing Team
Shilpa Joshi
Shilpa Joshi is one of India’s leading dietitian and diabetes educator. At her clinic, she uses principles of Medical Nutrition Therapy (MNT) for preventive and therapeutic care of various health issues.
Read more
We’re pretty sure almost everyone has enjoyed bread in some form – be it sandwiches, bread pakodas, or even the delicious shahi tukda. We all love bread, don’t we?
But does the brown colour of brown bread actually mean it is healthier? And if you’re trying to lose weight, is it the better choice compared to white bread?
You’ll find all your answers in this blog! 😊
080468 07733The Reality of Brown Bread: Not All It Seems to Be
Do you know the secret to really knowing how good a food item is? It’s not by looking at the fancy front of the packet but by flipping it over and reading what’s on the back! Yes, that’s where you’ll know the real truth about any item. And the same goes for bread.
So, to give you a full picture of brown bread, we did the hard work for you😊. We checked out the ingredient lists of some of the most popular brown breads available across many local shops, and here’s what we found!
| Category | Ingredients |
| Main Ingredients |
|
| Sweeteners & Fats |
|
| Preservatives | Calcium Propionate, INS 282
(keeps bread fresh, prevents microbial growth) |
| Salt & Flavor Enhancers | Iodized Salt, Common Salt, Caramel Flavor (adds flavour and colour) |
| Texture & Softness Agents | Emulsifiers (INS 471, 472e, 481), Bread Improvers (INS 170, 1100, 300, 510)
(makes bread softer, improves dough strength) |
| Others | Wheat Bran, Soya Flour (adds fiber and texture), Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C, INS 300
(improves texture and volume) |
| NOTE: This is an average – the amounts of ingredients like flour, sugar, and yeast used vary across different brands. |
Notice something surprising? Although the packaging might highlight “wheat flour” as a primary ingredient, it still contains refined wheat flour (maida), a highly processed ingredient that’s less beneficial for weight loss.
- Maida contains gluten, which gives the brown bread its soft texture and structure. However, its high glycemic index causes rapid spikes in blood sugar, which in turn means it is bad for weight loss goals.
- “Bread isn’t supposed to be sweet, so why would it have added sugar, right?” Well, not quite! Added sugar is actually a big concern.
- Sugar not only adds calories but also undergoes caramelization during baking, giving brown bread its brown colour. This colour can be misleading, creating the perception that the bread is made purely from whole wheat or atta when, in reality, it’s a combination of maida, sugar, and colour additives (in some brands). Because of this, we’re often drawn to its “healthy” look without actually knowing it’s the opposite.
- As shown in the table, oils like palm oil are commonly used in bread to make it soft and moist while also extending its shelf life, not to mention they are not as expensive as the other oils. However, during baking at very high temperatures, edible oil can undergo certain chemical changes, including oxidation and the potential formation of harmful compounds, depending on the baking conditions.
- This makes it an unhealthy choice, as it contains fats that may increase the risk of heart problems and weight gain.
- Now let’s pause here and think about what you use when making roti, chapati or paratha at home: ghee or a good quality edible oil, which we choose ourselves, both of which can be healthier options when used in moderation as compared to the palm oil used in most of the brown bread.
In fact, a garam roti, even without any ghee or oil, still tastes great with just gravy wali sabzi or sookhi sabzi, while bread without spreads like jam/butter/mayonnaises or toppings like omelette/cutlets etc. feels ‘incomplete.’
So, doesn’t a roti sound like the smarter, more wholesome choice for your meals? Think about it.
To sum up, although brown bread is marketed as a healthier option, it often contains ingredients that don’t support good health or weight loss.
Is your weight increasing your health riskHealthy Weight
Calculator
Why Is Roti a Better Choice than Brown Bread?
So, now we know that brown bread is often made with refined flour (maida), added sugar, and sometimes colour additives, making it quite similar to white bread despite its “healthy” appearance. But there’s another aspect to think about when choosing between roti and bread – freshness.
- Bread is usually made a few days before it reaches the store, and then it sits in your fridge for a few more days before you finish it. On the other hand, roti is made fresh at home, and even if kept overnight, it retains its nutrients.
- Now, you might say that you use bread because it is convenient. So here’s something worth noting – nowadays, you can even find readymade packed rotis in smaller supermarkets. These aren’t the frozen ones but fresh options that make roti just as convenient as picking up a loaf of bread!
So, if you’ve been choosing brown bread purely for convenience, fresh-packed rotis are a smarter, healthier option you can switch to.
And here’s the best part – rotis can easily replace bread in most dishes! Like roti wraps instead of sandwiches, roti-besan pakodas over bread pakodas, and doodh roti will beat shahi tukda any day. Just get creative and see how versatile rotis can be!
What is the Nutritional Value of Brown Bread?
Here’s a look at the nutritional breakdown of a popular brand of brown bread per 100g: We found that the calorie and carbohydrate content in both brown and white bread are quite similar, meaning – brown bread doesn’t offer a significant advantage for weight loss.
The difference in dietary fiber is minimal, and while fiber is essential for a weight-loss diet, 3 grams per 100 grams isn’t really high! You might not be getting as much fiber as you think.
| Nutrient | Nutritional value* (per 100 grams) | ||||
| Brown Bread | White Bread | Atta Bread | Other Breads (Garlic Bread, Butter Bread, Milk Bread) | Roti | |
| Equivalent Quantity | 1.25 – 2.5 Slices | 2 – 2.5 Roti | |||
| Energy (Kcal) | 260 – 300 | 250 – 260 | 250 – 260 | 260 – 320 | 175-250 |
| Protein (gm) | 8 – 10 | 7 – 8 | 8 – 9 | 8 – 10 | 5-7 |
| Carbohydrates (gm) | 53 – 57 | 54 – 55 | 52 – 53 | 52 – 57 | 37-50 |
| Total Sugar (gm) | 4 – 6 | 2 – 3 | 2 – 3 | 1 – 20 | 0 |
| Total Fat (gm) | 3 – 4 | 1-2 | 3 – 4 | 1 – 6 | 1-2 (recipe dependent) |
| Total Fiber (gm) | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 2-3 | 2-3 |
| Sodium (mg) | 320 – 520 | 400 – 410 | 430 – 440 | 370 – 620 | 10-15 |
* All the values provided for bread are based on commercially available brands and may vary depending on the specific brand and product.
* Two bread slices weigh 40-80 grams, while a medium roti weighs 40-50 grams. For 100 grams, this equals about 1.25 to 2.5 slices of bread or 2 to 2.5 rotis.
Why Does Roti Make You Feel Fuller Than Bread?
Roti keeps you fuller because it’s made from whole wheat flour, a minimally processed ingredient packed with fiber and nutrients. This slows down digestion, giving you steady energy and helping you stay satisfied for longer.
Bread, on the other hand, often contains refined flour along with added oils, sugars, and preservatives. These can cause quick blood sugar spikes, leaving you hungry sooner. As a result, you may end up eating more slices of bread (1.25 to 2.5 slices for 100 grams) to feel full compared to rotis (2 to 2.5 rotis for 100 grams). This means adding more calories, which isn’t ideal if you’re trying to manage your weight.
And roti, even if it is made overnight and you have it in the morning, just lightly heating it makes it a much healthier option.
Is Brown Bread Good for Weight Loss?
No, It isn’t.
But if you enjoy brown bread, consider it an occasional treat, much like mithai (sweets), rather than a daily staple. Make an informed choice and restrict yourself to the minimum number of slices.
A great tip is to pair each slice with fresh, fibre-rich veggies. This way, you’ll add nutrients, fiber, and flavour, making your meal much healthier without relying too heavily on the bread itself.
Watch this video featuring Shilpa Joshi, VP of Metabolic Health at Fitterfly, as she discusses the key factors to consider when choosing bread, along with our top recommendations:
How to Choose Weight Loss & Diet-Friendly Bread
Bread can still be part of a weight-loss diet if chosen wisely and eaten in moderation. Here’s how:
- Check the Ingredients: Look for whole wheat or whole grains as the first ingredient. Avoid options listing refined or enriched flour (maida).
- Avoid Added Sugars: Avoid bread with added sugars, such as high fructose corn syrup or malt. Opt for low – or no-sugar varieties.
- Look for Fiber: To help you stay full longer, choose bread with at least 0.4 – 1.2 grams of fiber per slice.
- Minimize Additives: Avoid breads with long lists of preservatives or artificial additives. Go for natural, minimally processed options.
- Verify Whole-Grain Claims: Don’t be fooled by brown-coloured bread. Check labels to ensure it’s truly whole grain or whole wheat.
- Pick Smaller Slices: Smaller slices or 100% whole-grain breads are lower in calories and better for weight management.
Enjoy bread mindfully by pairing it with sautéed veggies or paneer for a healthier twist.
Other Types of Bread Better Suited for Weight Loss
If you’re looking for healthier alternatives to traditional brown and white bread, here are some options that are commonly available in our local market/grocery shops/hypermarkets and can be easily added to your diet:
1. Whole Wheat Bread (100% Whole Wheat or Atta Bread)
Choose bread labelled “100% whole wheat” or “atta bread.” Made entirely from whole grains, it’s high in fiber, helping you stay full longer, aiding digestion, and stabilizing blood sugar for weight management.
2. Multigrain Bread
Multigrain bread offers extra fibre, vitamins, and minerals and is made from a blend of grains like oats, ragi, and jowar. Its nutrient-rich profile helps reduce cravings, improve digestion, and support weight loss.
3. Rye Bread
In specialty stores, rye bread is dense, fibre-rich, and has a low glycemic index. It helps keep you full longer, prevents blood sugar spikes, and is easier to digest for some due to lower gluten content.
4. Oats Bread
Oats bread combines whole oats and wheat, providing beta-glucan for appetite control and stable blood sugar. It’s a great choice for breakfast or snacks while managing weight.
5. Sprouted Grain Bread
Made from sprouted grains, this bread is nutrient-dense, easy to digest, and rich in fiber. It supports a balanced diet and helps curb cravings.
6. Bran Bread
Bran bread, made with wheat flour and bran, is packed with fiber to support digestion and keep you full longer. It’s a great option for managing hunger and aiding weight loss.
7. Milk Bread (Whole Wheat or Atta Version)
Look for milk bread made with whole wheat or atta as the primary ingredient. While it retains the soft texture of milk bread, the added fiber from whole wheat makes it a slightly better choice than refined white milk bread. However, check the label carefully to ensure whole wheat is the main ingredient, as not all “atta” milk bread may meet this standard.
| NOTE: Always read the ingredient label, as bread ingredients (even if they are 100% atta bread) vary by brand and region. If unlabelled (like local pao, ladi pav), you can’t be sure what’s in it. Look for whole grains or whole wheat as the first ingredient to make healthier choices. |
How We at Fitterfly Can Help You?
At Fitterfly, we understand how hard it is to give up bread if you love it. That’s why our nutrition coaches help you make smarter choices – teaching you to read labels, choose better options like whole-grain bread, and pair it with healthier sides so you don’t feel deprived.
But weight loss isn’t just about food. It’s also about how you move, sleep, and manage stress. Our Nutrition Coach guides you toward balanced meals and better eating habits, the Fitness Coach helps you stay active with plans that fit your routine, and the Success Coach helps you build healthy habits, stay consistent, and overcome challenges.
We make your weight loss journey simple, effective, and sustainable. Call us on 08046807733 to know more about how we can help you!
Lost 12 kg in 3 months without tough diet restrictions!
65kg
Happy members
EMI
Guarantee
4.8/5
Weight Loss Program
This blog provides general information for educational and informational purposes only and shouldn't be seen as professional advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is white bread good for weight loss?
No, white bread is high in refined flour and low in fiber, making it unsuitable for weight loss.
Is brown bread good for weight loss at night?
Eating any white or brown bread at night might not be ideal for weight loss, as it can spike blood sugar levels.
How many slices of brown bread a day for weight loss?
Even if you opt for brown bread, limit consumption to one or two slices a day. Overconsumption can hinder weight loss.
What should I look for when choosing brown bread for weight loss?
Look for “100% whole grain” or “whole wheat” with high fiber content and minimal added sugar and preservatives.
Can brown bread be a part of a balanced diet?
Yes, in moderation. However, it’s essential to choose varieties with whole grains and higher fiber for balanced nutrition.
Is a brown bread sandwich good for weight loss?
It depends on the bread's ingredients and what you put in the sandwich. Opt for whole-grain brown bread and fill it with nutrient-dense, low-calorie ingredients.
Which brown bread is good for weight loss?
Choose brands that use 100% whole grains and avoid those with refined flour (maida) and added sugars.
Does brown bread cause belly fat?
Eating brown bread with high refined flour and sugar content can contribute to weight gain, including belly fat.
Is brown bread and peanut butter good for weight loss?
Natural homemade peanut butter and whole-grain bread can support weight loss in when consumed in moderation. Avoid peanut butter with added sugar and brown bread made with refined flour. Portion control is key!
